FDA, Medical Device Industry Reach Agreement in Principle on Medical Device User Fees

FDA and representatives from the medical device industry have reached an agreement in principle on proposed recommendations for the third reauthorization of a medical device user fee program, according to an FDA press release.

The recommendations would authorize FDA to collect $595 million in user fees over five years, plus adjustments for inflation. Details of the agreement, such as the fee structure, are expected to be finalized soon.

Under a user fee program, the medical device industry agrees to pay fees to help fund a portion of FDA’s device review activities while FDA agrees to overall performance goals such as reviewing a certain percentage of applications within a particular timeframe.

The agreement in principle is the result of over a year of negotiations between FDA and the medical device industry. It strikes a careful balance between what the medical device industry agreed to pay and what FDA can accomplish with the amount of funding proposed. It would result in greater accountability, predictability, and transparency through such improvements as a more structured pre-submission process and earlier interactions between FDA and applicants. With the additional funding, FDA would be able to hire more than 200 full-time equivalent workers by the end of the five-year program. FDA and the medical device industry expect that the agreement in principle would result in a reduction in average total review times.

“I want to commend my staff and representatives from industry for their tireless work and commitment to achieving an agreement in principle on medical device user fees,” said FDA Commissioner Margaret A. Hamburg, MD. “Reauthorization of this important program is an essential component for advancing medical device innovation.”

Medical device industry associations that have reached an agreement in principle with FDA include the Advanced Medical Technology Association (AdvaMed), the Medical Device Manufacturers Association, and the Medical Imaging and Technology Alliance.

Congress first established the user fee program 10 years ago with the Medical Device User Fee and Modernization Act of 2002 (MDUFA I), prompted by growing concerns about the capacity and performance of the medical device review program. The five-year program was reauthorized with the Medical Device User Fee Act of 2007 (MDUFA II) and is set to expire on September 30.

MDUFA II authorized FDA to collect user fees for certain medical device applications, for the registration of certain medical device establishments, and for certain other purposes. Small businesses may qualify for a waiver from fees on certain submissions or may qualify for a reduced fee.

In September 2010, prior to beginning negotiations with regulated industry, FDA held a public meeting on the device user fee program attended by a variety of stakeholders including the medical device industry, scientific and academic experts, healthcare professionals, and representatives from patient and consumer advocacy groups. Stakeholders provided their assessment of the overall performance of the MDUFA program and their opinions about which aspects of the program should be retained, changed, or discontinued in order to further strengthen and improve the program.

Once the final details of the agreement with the medical device industry is completed, FDA will develop a package of proposed recommendations and give the public an opportunity to comment before they are submitted to Congress.

The date of the public meeting has yet to be determined.

-Richard Park